Water Testing

A Comprehensive Guide

The importance of rapid, accurate water testing

This article is a comprehensive and concise guide to understanding contamination of water sources, especially by pathogens and microbes.

It paints a global picture of water contamination and its consequences and delves directly into various pathogens that can be present in water and how they can harm us. Standard water management strategies to solve the issues associated with poor drinking water are described.

Special attention has been given to the concept of water quality monitoring and the different tests that have been developed to characterize water samples.

Towards the end of this article, standard methods for detection and quantification of E.coli and Total Coliform as standard indicators of microbiological contamination of water are explained.

Finally, it describes strategies and requirements for more efficient water quality monitoring, and how new technologies that can deliver water test data onsite and in real-time can revolutionize water quality monitoring programs.

Want to read, this over 13k+ word report, offline? Enter your email below to access the PDF

Global Water Contamination

Water may make up 71% of the surface of planet earth, but only 2.5% of this water is freshwater.

Fresh water is water that is not salty and is found in lakes, rivers or streams as opposed to salt water from the oceans. With a good portion of fresh water being in glaciers, polar ice caps, the atmosphere, soil, underground in the form of groundwater or too polluted to consume, only 0.5% of the earth’s water is available to use (1). These facts emphasize that water supplies are indeed finite and that water is undeniably our most valuable resource.

In 2010, the United Nations Human Rights Committee declared the “human right to safe drinking water and sanitation” (2). For water to be deemed acceptable and safe for drinking, many factors are taken into consideration from its clarity, taste, and chemical composition to the presence of microorganisms.

Around the world more than 2 billion people use a drinking water source that is contaminated with feces causing about 829,000 deaths per year due to unsafe drinking water (3). Diarrheal disease in general claims the lives of roughly 5,000 children every day (4) worldwide, particularly in developing countries. The leading cause of diarrheal death in children is unsafe drinking water with almost 1,200 deaths per day (5).

source: ourworldindata.org/childhood-diarrheal-diseases

The significance of the impact of water contaminated with disease causing microorganisms on human health can not be overstated. From the adverse effects of cholera on skin, to diarrhea, dysentery and loss of life, micro-biologically polluted water is dangerous.

Although the statistics presented here are not distributed equally around the world and developing countries form a large percentage of the affected population, water safety in developed countries should not be overlooked. In order to prevent life threatening conditions arising from unsafe drinking water, regular and frequent water testing procedures alongside boil water advisories have been implemented over the years. Boil water advisories are issued when water is known not to be safe or may be unsafe (6).

In North America, boil water advisories are commonplace, particularly in certain rural areas with poorer socio-economic communities, and governments are increasingly focused on eliminating these advisories and ensuring the right to safe water for all citizens.

There are several issues arising from having to boil drinking water with physical and mental implications. Boil water advisories, especially long term ones can hinder community trust in the quality of water. They can put financial burdens on communities if families have to rely on buying bottled water. Excessive water boiling can lead to the presence of mould in housings and force overcrowding of people, particularly in indigenous communities.

Overcrowding as well as the lack of running lead to contraction of methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus bacteria (MRSA). MRSA is the main antibiotic-resistant infection that affects Indigenous people disproportionately (7). At any given time, one in five indigenous communities in Canada is under a form of drinking water advisory (8)

References

1.United States bureau of reclamation, found at https://www.usbr.gov/mp/arwec/water-facts-ww-water-sup.html.

2.United Nations Human Rights, found at https://www.ohchr.org/en/issues/escr/pages/water.aspx.

3.World Health Organization, drinking water, found at https://www.who.int/news-room/fact-sheets/detail/drinking-water

4.UNICEF press release, found at https://www.unicef.org/media/media_19974.html.

5.Our world in data, found at https://ourworldindata.org/childhood-diarrheal-diseases.

6.Government of Canada drinking water advisories, found at https://www.sac-isc.gc.ca/eng/1538160229321/1538160276874

7. The conversation, Water crisis in First Nations communities runs deeper than long-term drinking water advisories, Corinna Dally-Starna, found at https://theconversation.com/water-crisis-in-first-nations-communities-runs-deeper-than-long-term-drinking-water-advisories-148977

8. Department of Geography and Planning, University of Saskatchewan, Saskatoon,

Indigenous perspectives on water security in Saskatchewan, Canada, Water 2020, 12(3), 810, found at https://doi.org/10.3390/w12030810

Water Pollution - What's in our Water?

Water pollution occurs whenever a substance, such as chemicals or microorganisms, is released into water via the ocean, streams, lakes, rivers, estuaries or groundwater and interferes with the beneficial use of the water or the natural function of the ecosystem (1).

It may also be considered water pollution when energy in the form of radioactivity or heat is released into bodies of water.

Various substances can pollute water bodies in the form of the following contaminants:

  • physical: suspended sediment or organic material.
  • chemical: nitrogen, bleach, salts, pesticides, metals, toxins produced by bacteria, and human or animal drugs.
  • biological (microbial): organisms in water such as bacteria and viruses.
  • radioactive:radioactivesubstances such as cesium, plutonium and uranium

These contaminants can be in the form of pathogenic microorganisms, toxic chemicals, petroleum, putrescible organic waste, sediments, plant nutrients (mostly nitrogen and phosphorus) and radioactive materials (1,2).

Emerging contaminants such as pharmaceuticals and personal care products as well as microplastics also cause water pollution.

Water pollution is not distributed equally around the world. More than 2 billion do not have access to safe drinking water and 159 million people drink water directly from untreated surface water sources like streams or lakes (4).

According to the United Nations Environment Program (UNEP) while many developed countries deal with eutrophication(excessive availability of nutrients that leads to dense growth of plants), heavy metals, emerging contaminants, nitrates and land degradation due to salinity, their water quality has significantly improved over the years.

Developing countries however are facing increasing water pollution as urban populations grow, the consumption of everyday living materials increases and more untreated wastewater is released into the environment (5).

source: who.int/water_sanitation_health/monitoring/coverage/slide-1-gif.gif
source: worldbank.org/en/news/infographic/2019/08/20/impacts-of-water-pollution

Drinking water contaminants pose a harm to public health. As stated, biological or microbial contaminants are the most dangerous pollutants and responsible for water borne diseases and deaths all around the world. There were 16.97 deaths per 100,000 people in the world from unsafe water sources reported in 2017.

Dirty water causes the death of one human being every 10 seconds (7) and

up to 18 million cases of waterborne diseases are reported in North America every year (8).

It is worth noting that even in developed countries factors such as race, ethnicity and income can play a role on availability of safe water.

source: ourworldindata.org/grapher/death-rates-unsafe-water?time=2017&country=~OWID_WRL

Causes of Microbial Water Contamination

Microorganisms such as

  • bacteria: common microscopic single-celled organisms.
  • viruses: microscopic parasites that thrive and reproduce in a host body.
  • protozoa: specific group of enteric pathogens.
  • parasites: organism that lives on, or inside of, another organism

Untreated municipal wastewater is the most dangerous contributor to water ecosystems in terms of excess nutrients and microorganisms.

A startling 80% of the world’s wastewater, mostly untreated, is released into the environment (3).

  1. Britannica encyclopedia, found at https://www.britannica.com/science/water-pollution.
  2. United States Environmental Protection Agency, contaminant candidate list (CCL) and regulatory determination, found at https://www.epa.gov/ccl/types-drinking-water-contaminants
  3. National Resources Defense Council Water Pollution: Everything You Need to Know, found at https://www.nrdc.org/stories/water-pollution-everything-you-need-know
  4. World Health Organization, public health, environmental and social determinants of health, found at https://www.who.int/mediacentre/infographic/environment/en/
  5. United Nations Environment Program, A Snapshot of the World’s Water Quality: Towards a global assessment, found at https://uneplive.unep.org/media/docs/assessments/unep_wwqa_report_web.pdf
  6. The World Bank, The impacts of water pollution, found at https://www.worldbank.org/en/news/infographic/2019/08/20/impacts-of-water-pollution
  7. The world counts, found at https://www.theworldcounts.com/challenges/planet-earth/freshwater/deaths-from-dirty-water/story
  8. Waterlogic infographic, found at https://www.waterlogic.com/en-us/resources-blog/water-pollution-facts/

Water Needs in the Future

Water stress means the demand for water exceeds the amount available for use or the quality is poor and restricts its use. Water stress is exacerbated by:

  • climate change
  • increasing water scarcity
  • population growth
  • changes in demographic
  • increasing urbanization (2)

The UN designated its Sustainable Development Goal (SDG) 6 to achieve universal and equitable access to safe and affordable water for all by 2030. That is why management of water sources is becoming increasingly important. Reuse and recycling of wastewater (especially for irrigation), water quality monitoring(including water testing), reversing climate change and conserving water as a few of the steps we can take to battle water stress in the world. Better water management and consequently making water available to everyone will also have a positive impact on the world economy. 263 million people have to spend at least 30 min per round trip to collect water (3).

This time can be allocated to more productive activities as well as reduce the health risk on individuals. Access to improved sources of water for children who are at the highest risk of water related diseases can result in better health, potentially lead to better school attendance and possibly a better future for individuals and communities.

  1. World Health Organization, Drinking water, found at https://www.who.int/news-room/fact-sheets/detail/drinking-water
  2. World Health Organization, A guide to equitable water safety planning, found at https://apps.who.int/iris/rest/bitstreams/1210410/retrieve
  3. World Health Organization, found at https://www.who.int/water_sanitation_health/monitoring/coverage/slide-1-gif.gif?ua=1

What is Water Quality and Why Does it Matter?

Water quality can be considered as a measure of the suitability of water for its intended use, in terms of physical, chemical or biological characteristics (1). Water quality is very important since poor water quality can have adverse effects on human life. As stated earlier, any substance that alters the properties of water so it is no longer beneficial, safe or threatens the function of the ecosystem is considered a pollutant or contaminant. Contaminants in water may have the following effects on people:

  • aesthetic: water may taste bad or have an unpleasant odour
  • cosmetic: water may have unpleasant effects on a person’s appearance
  • acute health effects: symptoms occurs hours or days after consumption of contaminated water
  • chronic health effects: health deteriorates after years of consuming contaminated water (2)

Other than direct health effects, poor water quality can impact economic and social conditions around the world that can affect the quality of life. As emphasized by World Bank Group president David Malpass, “Clean water is a key factor for economic growth. Deteriorating water quality is stalling economic growth, worsening health conditions, reducing food production, and exacerbating poverty in many countries,”. Economic growth is intertwined with the quality of the environment, especially water, so much so that the World Bank estimates that water pollution can reduce economic growth by up to a third (3).

Suffice to say that water quality is of the utmost importance. This makes water monitoring and testing a significant step in assessing water quality.Around the world, there is a focus on the presence and monitoring of microbiological contaminants in the form of microorganisms in water because the health effects of these are the most pronounced.

What are Pathogens?

Microorganisms or microbes in general are small living things with dimensions in the micron (micrometers) range or smaller. Microbes are roughly ten times smaller than the average thickness of the human hair and cannot be seen without the help of microscopes. Not all microorganisms are harmful; in fact many microorganisms around us help us and the environment to stay healthy. The microorganisms that are capable of causing harm to their hosts are called pathogens. This harm can be caused in the form of competing with the host for metabolic resources (food), destroying the host cells and tissues or producing toxins (1).

Pathogens can be categorized as:

  • bacteria: common microscopic single-celled organisms.
  • viruses: microscopic parasites that thrive and reproduce in a host body.
  • parasites: organism that lives on, or inside of, another organism
  • fungi: includes microorganisms such as yeasts and molds, as well as the more familiar mushrooms.
  • algae: diverse group of aquatic organisms that have the ability to conduct photosynthesis

Remember that not all microorganisms are pathogens. For example, yogurt is made by exposing milk to helpful bacteria (lactobacillus acidophilus).

Representation of different microorganisms under the microscope

 

Grand prismatic hot spring, Yellowstone national park. Different bacteria at different temperatures create the magnificent colors of the rainbow.

 

  1. The free dictionary, definition of pathogenic microorganism, found at https://medical-dictionary.thefreedictionary.com/pathogenic+microorganism
  2. Biologywise, helpful bacteria examples, found at https://biologywise.com/helpful-bacteria-examples

Pathogens / microbes / viruses that Exist in Drinking Water

Below are some of the harmful and dangerous pathogens that can exist in water and need to be monitored and tested in laboratories. The frequency of occurrence and the extent of danger requires some of them to be monitored and tested more regularly.
  • Bacteria

Escherichia coli (E. coli), Coliform*(fecal and non fecal), Legionella pneumophila, Salmonella, Campylobacter (C. jejuni &C. coli)1and Vibrio cholerae (V. Cholerae)2 *E. coli is a fecal coliform
  • Viruses

Enteroviruses(such as poliovirus, echovirus, coxsackieviruses), Hepatitis A, adenovirus, astrovirus, E viruses, rotavirus, norovirus and other caliciviruses*. *viruses that are excreted through the body via urine like polyomaviruses and cytomegalovirus can potentially be spread through water. Viruses like influenza andcoronaviruses have been suggested to be transmitted through drinking water, but the current evidence is inconclusive3.
  • Protozoa (Parasites)

Cryptosporidium, Giardia lamblia, Toxoplasma gondii, Entamoeba histolytica, Cyclospora cayetanensis, Isospora belli, Blastocystis hominis, Balantidium coli, Acanthamoeba spp., Sarcocystis spp. and Naegleria spp4.
  • Fungi

Fungi are not as heavily regulated in guidelines for water monitoring and are listed as “nuisance organisms” but this does not mean they are necessarily allowed in water. These are some of the species and genera of fungi in water (especially tap water) that can also be present in the air. Aspergillus(e.g. mould), yeast of the gerena Candida, Exophiala, Fusarium, Malassezia, Ochroconis, Penicillium, Phialophora, Phomaand Rhinocladiella, Cryptococcus and Rhodotorula,and black yeast from the generaAureobasidium5
  • Algae

phytoplankton blooms, micro-algal blooms: Harmful Algal Blooms (HAB) All these pathogens can cause mild to severe illnesses in humans if they exist in higher than Maximum Contaminant Levels(MCL) outlined in drinking water quality monitoring regulations*. Higher amounts of pathogens in waters that enter the environment can also hurt the ecosystem. In order to monitor the presence of these pathogens, indicators have been chosen to reflect a problem with water quality. Indicators were chosen because they are:
  • always present when pathogens are present in the water;
  • larger in number compared to specific pathogens in water;
  • easy to analyse in water samples;
  • faster and less expensive to test than specific pathogens;
  • survive better than pathogens in water; and,
  • not present if water is not contaminated.6
The United States Environmental Protection Agency(USEPA) regulates turbidity, E. coliand Total Coliform(fecal and non-fecal coliform) as these indicators1. Bear in mind that turbidity is the cloudiness of water, not a microbe; but it can be a suitable environment for the growth of pathogens and disrupt disinfection. Total Coliformcan be found in the intestinal tract of animals but not all coliforms are pathogens. They can come from fecal materials, soil, water or grains. Coliform bacteriabelong to the Enterobacteriaceae family and include a number of bacterial species. Although the Maximum Contaminant Level (MCL) for Total Coliformis also non detectable per 100 ml of water, the revised rule proposed by the USEPA in 2010 eliminated MCL requirements for Total Coliformand replaced it with MCL for E. colias well as monitoring, assessment and corrective action for the treatment systems in place for coliforms where there are treatment options available7. The following table includes the species, sources and illnesses caused by some of the most important pathogenic microorganisms in water.
Pathogen Source Illness
Bacteria
E. coli Sewage overflow, Improperly working sewage system, Agricultural runoff, Stormwater runoff, Flooding8,9 Gastroenteritis, Pneumonia,Urinary tract infection
Legionella Pneumophila Presence in water distribution systems, Construction, Water main breaks, Changes in municipal water quality, Biofilm, Scale and sediment, Water temperature fluctuations, pH fluctuations, Inadequate levels of disinfectant, Changes in water pressure, Water stagnation10 Legionellosis: Pontiac Fever, Legionnaires’ Disease
Salmonella Sewage overflow, Improperly working sewage system, Agricultural runoff, Storm water runoff, flooding11 Gastroenteritis, Salmonellosis, Typhoid, Reactive Arthritis
C. jejuni Sewage overflow, Improperly working sewage system, Agricultural runoff, Storm water runoff, flooding12 Gastroenteritis, Campylobacteriosis
Viruses
Poliovirus Sewage overflow, Improperly working sewage system (mainly from humans), Overland runoff, underground seepage13 Paralytic poliomyelitis
Rotavirus Sewage overflow, Improperly working sewage system (from humans), Stormwater runoff, Flooding14 Gastroenteritis
Hepatitis A. Sewage overflow, Inadequately treated water and wastewater15 Liver inflammation
Protozoa
Cryptosporidium Sewage overflow, Improperly working sewage system, Agricultural runoff, Stormwater runoff, Flooding16 Cryptosporidiosis (may include fever, diarrhea and vomiting), More severe harm to digestive or respiratory tract in immunocompromised persons
Giradia Lamblia Sewage overflow, Improperly working sewage system, Agricultural runoff, Stormwater runoff, Flooding17 Giardiasis
Fungi
Aspergillus Inadequately treated water or wastewater and the presence of organic materials, pH change, Water temperature fluctuations, Changes in water hardness, Changes in chemical composition of water6,18 Aspergillosis
Fungi from the genus Exophiala Sewage overflow, Inadequately treated water or wastewater and the presence of organic materials, pH change, Water temperature fluctuations, Changes in water hardness, Changes in chemical composition of water,6,18 Traumatic cutaneous infections, Keratitis, Onychomycosis, Otitis externa, Lung infections in patients with cystic fibrosis, Disseminated mycosis in immunocompromised patients, even involving the brain6
Algae
Phytoplanktons causing HAB Nutrient pollution in the form of excess nitrogen and phosphorus caused by: Agriculture, Stormwater, Inadequately treated Wastewater, Fossil fuels, Household runoff 19 Eye, skin, nose, throat and respiratory irritation20, HAB toxin poisoning from eating contaminated seafood21
  1. Watertech online, Bacteria and viruses commonly found in drinking water, found at https://www.watertechonline.com/wastewater/article/15545721/bacteria-and-viruses-commonly-found-in-drinking-water
  2. World Health Organization, Water-related diseases, found at https://www.who.int/water_sanitation_health/diseases-risks/diseases/cholera/en/
  3. Waterborne Viruses: A Barrier to Safe Drinking Water,Gall, A. M., Mariñas, B. J., Lu, Y., & Shisler, J. L. (2015). PLoS pathogens, 11(6), e1004867, found at https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.ppat.1004867
  4. Protozoan Parasites in Drinking Water: A System Approach for Improved Water, Sanitation and Hygiene in Developing Countries.Omarova, A., Tussupova, K., Berndtsson, R., Kalishev, M., & Sharapatova, K. (2018). International journal of environmental research and public health, 15(3), 495. found at https://doi.org/10.3390/ijerph15030495
  5. Fungal Contaminants in Drinking Water Regulation? A Tale of Ecology, Exposure, Purification and Clinical Relevance, Novak Babic, M., Gunde-Cimerman, N., Vargha, M., Tischner, Z., Magyar, D., Veríssimo, C., Sabino, R., Viegas, C., Meyer, W., & Brandão, J. (2017). International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, 14(6), 636. Found at https://doi.org/10.3390/ijerph14060636
  6. APEC water, The Importance to Test for Total Coliforms and Fecal Coliforms in Water, found at https://www.freedrinkingwater.com/water_quality/quality1/33-08-test-for-fecal-and-total-coliform.htm
  7. Government of Canada, Page 3: Guidelines for Canadian Drinking Water Quality: Guideline Technical Document – Total Coliforms, found at https://www.canada.ca/en/health-canada/services/publications/healthy-living/guidelines-canadian-drinking-water-quality-guideline-technical-document-total-coliforms/page-3-guidelines-canadian-drinking-water-quality-guideline-technical-document-total-coliforms.html
  8. National Resources Defense Council Water Pollution: Everything You Need to Know, found athttps://www.nrdc.org/stories/water-pollution-everything-you-need-know
  9. Center for Disease Control and Prevention, What is Escherichia coli O157:H7?, found at https://www.cdc.gov/healthywater/drinking/private/wells/disease/e_coli.html
  10. Center for Disease Control and Prevention, What Owners and Managers of Buildings and Healthcare Facilities Need to Know about the Growth and Spread of Legionella, found athttps://www.cdc.gov/legionella/wmp/overview/growth-and-spread.html
  11. Center for Disease Control and Prevention , Salmonella and Drinking Water from Private Wells, found athttps://www.cdc.gov/healthywater/drinking/private/wells/disease/salmonella.html#:~:text=Salmonella%20may%20be%20found%20in,water%20runoff%2C%20and%20agricultural%20runoff
  12. Center for Disease Control and Prevention, Campylobacter and Drinking Water from Private Wells, found at https://www.cdc.gov/healthywater/drinking/private/wells/disease/campylobacter.html
  13. World Health Organization, The Biologic Principles of Poliovirus Eradication, Task Force for Child Survival and Development, Atlanta, Georgia; Global Programme for Vaccines and Immunization, found at https://watermark.silverchair.com/175-Supplement_1-S286.pdf?token=AQECAHi208BE49Ooan9kkhW_Ercy7Dm3ZL_9Cf3qfKAc485ysgAAAtUwggLRBgkqhkiG9w0BBwagggLCMIICvgIBADCCArcGCSqGSIb3DQEHATAeBglghkgBZQMEAS4wEQQMyBzv2ngqG1JDeJhhAgEQgIICiGLKE2oebYYHRpjYv1JQuCbkpnaqMwoqMJJ4MPw4P_7VtWoADVIPO_pVDXhDHa01nC_XdWuTkOVEYsyfILHq0QSqhBm7jo6YW4-GakWEoCjeuEKZspeKY5cMNvApFMwlLsuCkF2Fqb88iOlRDvmYGm6cKiiHMa0lltK9QteubTU_SPOmc5EZsY6saakWbhnafY66aNhzYDApTBsEAh04tKlbj2K3wa3h_9YvHaheHjXb-9wITXCFgcBvK_IxGPGcNL-wqt2riQsOIiOD8AOk5s5mxgpg5Pn9mawE-Mirhypd0yURSveYdsos5kIK9VGbdzSK254E7U18YiVq86nDhmylFZqITK8MQlH5lIlP0RuvUOn4_11AHHlqxbpyZ2jx2MnB_pQWaFfM-eEobGB_6gts8mjMauysJWqEeczygNj6sqq_WDPZhwD–b0wc_m_l5HCmRlL0wpY7JEb8EJg8KGXsHeRduaHmgvQCDfFYh0TEl77Ub81RrvqrPPzOqjgOlIJ5oBHWOfYrTYwSf-897LK2FqPILLSNDxiTiOC38S34b-DU3ELtjBujo-LJGzSMCI1-BLhinjKSkTWct5NUhmK-6aeRPxyD5F_om7BZtwb9QgEP0mTdUgOxNdsROp5KrK6viKqw7LWAomQUkW_94v0KBhg–K9xXTVp75gxHcHl7jqcTfFwdHOyq4n430BbnaxH66R9gUgk5b1Sb4wJ-QtNEclNCXey5bqeeVBfkl2jqofuOhbIlwUcPMOgW9s-hQdCXWZT5Ae6imTsZ0BnxHku_Z5AmTpVDehpv8DajnuPgoMrPlzWRBtp41wlkMAD7C6bXrzx3yMXk1C9zkaR5JY01fOYjkVrg
  14. Center for Disease Control and Prevention, Rotavirus and drinking water from private wells, found at https://www.cdc.gov/healthywater/drinking/private/wells/disease/rotavirus.html#:~:text=The%20virus%20may%20be%20found,and%20polluted%20storm%20water%20runoff.
  15. World Health Organization, Hepatitis A., found at https://www.who.int/news-room/fact-sheets/detail/hepatitis-a
  16. Center for Disease Control and Prevention, What is cryptosporidiosis?, found at https://www.cdc.gov/healthywater/drinking/private/wells/disease/cryptosporidium.html
  17. Center for Disease Control and Prevention, What is giardiasis?, found at https://www.cdc.gov/healthywater/drinking/private/wells/disease/giardia.html
  18. Safe drinking water foundation, Fungi, found at https://www.safewater.org/fact-sheets-1/2017/12/29/fungi
  19. United States Environmental Protection Agency, found at Nutrient pollution, sources and solutions, found at https://www.epa.gov/nutrientpollution/sources-and-solutions
  20. Center for Disease Control and Prevention, HAB associated illness, Freshwater environments, found at https://www.cdc.gov/habs/illness-symptoms-freshwater.html
  21. Center for Disease Control and Prevention, HAB associated illness, Marine environments, found at https://www.cdc.gov/habs/illness-symptoms-marine.html

What are the Different Forms of Water Bacterium?

To reiterate, there are different types of bacteria that can exist in water.

Escherichia coli (E. coli), Coliform (fecal and non fecal), Legionella pneumophila, Salmonella and Campylobacter (C. jejuni &C. coli) are some of the species that can find their way into water and cause different illnesses in animals and humans.

As mentioned, the most common ways for these bacteria to end up in water are inadequate water treatment, sewage overflow, improperly working sewage system, agricultural runoff, storm water runoff, flooding and in some cases changes in the physical and chemical properties of water.

Specific to drinking water, faulty piping systems in the distribution network can lead to pathogens in water. Pathogenic bacteria can be responsible for a variety of diseases like gastroenteritis or infectious diarrhea, pneumonia, urinary tract infection, legionellosis, typhoid, campylobacteriosis and cholera that may unfortunately lead to loss of life. As previously stated, dirty water causes the death of one human being every 10 seconds.

Below, we’ll focus on some of the bacterial species in water and their adverse effects, followed by information on water management. Water management is paramount in preventing waterborne diseases. Water treatment as well as water quality monitoring including water sample testing are the most effective forms of water management.

E. coli Bacteria in Water

source(public domain on wikipedia from CDC) en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Escherichia_coli#/media/File:Scanning_electron_micrograph_of_an_E._coli_colony.jpg
source (public domain on wikipedia from CDC) en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Escherichia_coli#/media/File:Scanning_electron_micrograph_of_an_E._coli_colony.jpg

Escherichia coli (E. coli) are a large group of Gram negative*, rod shaped bacteria with about 1-2 micrometers in length and 0.5 micrometers in radius. E. coli bacteria are naturally found in the environment and the intestines of humans and animals. They can also be found in food and water.

Some strains can cause urinary tract infection and pneumonia. Some pathogenic E. coli belong to the group of bacteria called STEC (Shiga toxin-producing E. coli) also known as VTEC (Verocytotoxin-producing E. coli) or EHEC enterohemorrhagic E. coli. The most commonly identified strain of STEC is E. coli O157:H7; O157 and H7 refer to the antigens present in this strain1,2,3,4. E. coli O157:H7 is a hazardous strain although there are several other strains of pathogenic EHEC as well as other pathotypes of E. coli(not belonging to EHEC) that cause sickness.

Transmission usually occurs through coming in contact with the pathogen through ingestion via food, drinking contaminated water, contact with cattle, contact with the feces of infected people, and the like.

Since E. coli exists in the digestive tract of humans and animals, it can end up in different bodies of water from feces, including sources of drinking water such as rivers and lakes or private wells through sewage overflow, improperly working sewage system, agricultural runoff, storm water runoff and flooding .

Even small amounts of E. coli in water can be dangerous and lead to illness. Therefore the allowable amount or MCL in drinking water is non-detectable/absent in 100 ml.

Some international guidelines specify the MCL as zero in 100 ml of drinking water (5).

Extensive research has been done on the survival of E. coli in water and the conclusion is that since many factors such as temperature, sunlight and nutrients can affect the survival of E. coli, estimates and models are made for various conditions. Further field studies will help future estimates and calculations. For example, at a temperature of 14-20°C E. coli survives for less than 1-10 weeks in natural surface waters. In groundwater it can survive for 3-14 weeks at 10°C (6,7).

The dependence of the survival of E. coli on various environmental conditions means that regular and frequent monitoring, testing and assessment of water quality is crucial when it comes to E. coli to ensure the safety of water for humans and the environment.

*Gram negative bacteria have a particular substance called peptidoglycan in their cell wall that lose the crystal violet stain in the Gram staining method.

  1. National Research Council (US) Steering Group for the Workshop on Size Limits of Very Small Microorganisms. Size Limits of Very Small Microorganisms: Proceedings of a Workshop. Washington (DC): National Academies Press (US); 1999. Correlates of Smallest Sizes for Microorganisms, found at https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK224751/
  2. Center for Disease Control and Prevention, E. coli, questions and answers, found at https://www.cdc.gov/ecoli/general/index.html
  3. Microbiologics, Pick a Pathogen: Non-O157 Shiga Toxin-Producing E. coli (STEC), found at https://www.microbiologics.com/core/media/media.nl?id=179883&c=915960&h=684d2af718730929c93d&_xt=.pdf
  4. UNICEF press release, found at https://www.unicef.org/media/media_19974.html.
  5. Health Canada, Guidelines for Canadian Drinking Water Quality Guideline Technical Document Escherichia coli, found at https://www.canada.ca/content/dam/canada/health-canada/migration/healthy-canadians/publications/healthy-living-vie-saine/water-ecoli-eau/alt/water-ecoli-eau-eng.pdf
  6. Government of Canada, Escherichia coli in Drinking Water, found at https://www.canada.ca/en/health-canada/programs/consultation-e-coli-drinking-water/document.html
  7. Physical Factors Impacting the Survival and Occurrence of Escherichia coli in Secondary Habitats, Petersen, F.; Hubbart, J.A. Water 2020, 12, 1796. Found at https://www.mdpi.com/2073-4441/12/6/1796
  8. Water, Sanitation and Hygiene, United Nations. Found at

https://www.unwater.org/water-facts/water-sanitation-and-hygiene/.

Coliform Bacteria in Water

Coliform bacteria belong to the family of Enterobacteriaceae. They are also Gram-negative, rod shaped bacteria like E. Coli bacteria. According to the different Standard Method (SM) of testing for coliform, this group of bacteria may be defined as (stated by Health Canada (1)):

  • For SM 9221 (Multiple Tube Fermentation): “all facultative anaerobic, Gram-negative, non spore forming, rod shaped bacteria that ferment lactose with gas and acid formation within 48 hours at 35°C”
  • For SM 9222 (Membrane Filtration): “many facultative anaerobic, Gram-negative, non spore forming, rod shaped bacteria that develop red colonies with a metallic (golden) sheen within 24 hours at 35°C on an Endo-type medium containing lactose”
  • For SM 9223 (Enzyme Substrate): “all bacteria possessing the enzyme ß-galactosidase, which cleaves a chromogenic substrate (e.g., ortho-nitrophenyl-ß-d-galactopyranoside), resulting in release of a chromogen (e.g. ortho-nitrophenol).”

These definitions refer to three roughly equivalent groups of coliform including a variety of species of various genera. Total Coliform consists of non-fecal and fecal coliforms, which means whether or not the bacteria originate from feces.

Non-fecal coliforms normally occur in nature and are found everywhere. Not all coliforms are pathogenic. The following table includes some genera of coliforms (1,2).

Coliform bacteriaFecalNon-fecal
Escherichia
Enterobacter
Klebsiella
Budvicia
Leclercia
Citrobacter
Pantoea
Serratia
Erwinia
Hafnia

The important role of Total Coliforms in water is that they are indicator organisms that can determine the presence of pathogens in water and its safety. As indicators Total Coliforms also help to assess the effectiveness of water treatment in different areas.

This is especially important for water sources used for providing drinking water.

Health Canada requires MCL or the maximum acceptable concentration (MAC) for Total Coliforms in water leaving a treatment plant and in non-disinfected groundwater leaving the well to be undetectable per 100 mL of water. This is also the case with WHO, the USEPA and EU (European Union) whenever water is disinfected.

Coliforms can survive in water from days to months depending on the environmental conditions. They are normally larger in numbers than other microorganisms in water. That’s one of the main reasons why they are perfect candidates for being indicators in water testing and quality monitoring.

  1. Health Canada (2020). Guidelines for Canadian Drinking Water Quality: Guideline Technical Document – Total coliforms. Water and Air Quality Bureau, Healthy Environments and Consumer Safety Branch, Health Canada, Ottawa, Ontario. (Catalogue No. H144-8/2020E- PDF). Found at https://www.canada.ca/content/dam/hc-sc/documents/services/healthy-living/water-coliforms-coliformes-eau/water-coliforms-coliformes-eau-eng.pdf
  2. Comparison of fecal coliform agar and violet red bile lactose agar for fecal coliform enumeration in foods, A. Leclercq, C. Wanegue, P. Baylac, Appl Environ Microbiol., 2002 Apr; 68(4):1631-8. Found at: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/11916678/
  3. UNICEF press release, found at https://www.unicef.org/media/media_19974.html.
  4. 5.Our world in data, found at https://ourworldindata.org/childhood-diarrheal-diseases.

Legionella Pneumophila Bacteria in Water

source: en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Legionella#/media/File%3AHarmannella_entrapping_Legionella.png

According to WHO, species of the genus Legionella are Gram-negative, non spore forming, rod shaped, bacteria that are aerobic, which means they can survive and grow in an oxygenated environment. They have a non fermentative metabolism and require L-cysteine and iron salts to grow (1). Free-living legionellae are 0.3-0.9 micrometers wide and about 1.3 micrometers long. They can grow to 2-6 micrometers in vitro (outside the body) and are able to form filaments of 20 micrometers long.

Legionella bacteria are found naturally in freshwater environments. Small amounts of the bacteria in freshwater are not normally cause for concern and are not affiliated with illnesses; however, if Legionella finds its way into building water systems it can be a health risk. Some strains of Legionella like Legionella pneumophila can cause Legionellosis in the form of Legionnaires’ disease, which is a lung infection (pneumonia). The symptoms include coughing, fever, shortness of breath, muscle aches and Headaches. Legionellosis can also be a less severe illness in the form of Pontiac fever, which includes fever and muscle aches.

The below factors may lead to the growth of Legionella in building water systems (2,3):

  • presence in water distribution systems
  • construction
  • scale and sediment
  • water main breaks
  • pH fluctuations
  • changes in municipal water quality
  • biofilm formation
  • water temperature fluctuations (especially 25°C – 42°C)
  • inadequate levels of disinfectant
  • changes in water pressure
  • water stagnation

For more information on where Legionella can grow or spread that may put humans at risk visit the CDC webpage on Legionella.

There are no reports of person to person transmission of Legionella. Transmission commonly occurs by inhaling aerosols of contaminated water. In the United states, cases of Legionnaires’ disease have risen 350% from 2000 through 2016. The CDC states that it is unclear what the reason is for this increase but speculates it might be attributed to factors such as more awareness and more testing (representing an artifact in numbers increasing) , increased susceptibility of the population, increased Legionella in the environment or a combination of such factors.

Although many countries do not have the means to report cases, WHO estimates that in Australia, Europe and the United States there are about 10-15 cases per million people (5). Regular testing, maintenance, cleaning and adequate disinfection of water and air conditioning systems, water cooling towers, manual and automatic faucets, water filters, etc will help to minimize the growth of the legionella bacterium as there are currently no vaccines available.

Bear in mind that not everyone is prone to getting infected. People, especially travelers over the age of 50, current or former smokers, people with chronic lung conditions, or are immunocompromised are at a higher risk (4).

Characteristically, legionellae multiply inside protozoa, but the presence of some cyanobacteria genera can promote their growth as well. In natural environments (except for thermal waters and water in tropical regions) legionellae concentrations fall below 1 cfu/ml* as their replication rates are low (1). In building water systems and water distribution systems where temperatures fall between 20°C and 50°C, legionellae frequently colonize. The bacterial cells can survive in aerosols for hours and last longer in water even in harsh conditions (6).

Due to their slow growth and metabolism, laboratory methods to test and detect Legionella are often slow processes that may take up to 14 days.

There are other methods such as biosensors or PCR (polymerase chain reaction) being developed to make rapid sensors for the detection of pathogenic Legionella such as Legionella pneumophila.

*cfu stands for colony forming unit, a measure of the concentration of microorganisms.

  1. World Health Organization, Legionella, found at https://www.who.int/water_sanitation_health/dwq/admicrob4.pdf
  2. Center for Disease Control and Prevention, Legionnaires’ Disease and Pontiac Fever), What owners and managers of buildings and healthcare facilities need to know about the growth and spread of Legionella, found at https://www.cdc.gov/legionella/wmp/overview/growth-and-spread.html
  3. Center for Disease Control and Prevention, Legionnaires’ Disease and Pontiac Fever), Signs and Symptoms, found at https://www.cdc.gov/legionella/about/signs-symptoms.html
  4. Center for Disease Control and Prevention, Travelers’ health, found at https://wwwnc.cdc.gov/travel/yellowbook/2020/travel-related-infectious-diseases/legionellosis-legionnaires-disease-and-pontiac-fever
  5. World health organization, Legionellosis (Legionnaires’ disease), found at https://www.who.int/news-room/q-a-detail/legionellosis-legionnaires-disease
  6. Ten questions concerning the aerosolization and transmission of Legionella in the built environment, A. J. Prussin, D. O. Schwake, L. C. Marr, Building and Environment 123 (2017) 684-695, found at https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0360132317302597

Campylobacter Bacteria in Water

source(public domain) en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Campylobacter_jejuni#/media/File%3AARS_Campylobacter_jejuni.jpg

The word Campylobactermeans “curved rod” from the Greek words kampylos (curved) and baktron (rod). This genus of bacteria belongs to the family Campylobacteraceae. Campylobacter bacteria are rod shaped, Gram negative, non spore forming, microaerophilic (require oxygen to survive but less oxygen than available in the atmosphere) and are non-fermenting. The cells are typically 0.2-0.9 micrometers in diameter by 0.5-5 micrometers in length and can grow to be as long as 8.0 micrometers.

The species C. jejuni is a common cause of food poisoning and it can be found in poultry and animal feces. Consumption of food or water contaminated with C. jejuni can cause Gastroenteritis and Campylobacteriosis which may induce symptoms like fever, diarrhea and abdominal pain. Campylobacter (C. jejuni and C. coli) is one of the leading causes of bacterial diarrheal disease in the world with 96 million cases in 2010 (1,2,3,4).

Together with E. coli, Legionella, Rotavirus and Norovirus, Campylobacter now makes up one of the leading causes of disease in humans(5) including contaminated water as one of the sources of disease.

Although a large portion of the cases of Campylobacteriosis are caused by contaminated food, water can also be contaminated with Campylobacter like C. jejuniand C. coli through the feces of animals. Sewage overflow, improperly working sewage system, agricultural runoff, storm water runoff or flooding can introduce feces into water. Transmission of disease other than through contaminated water is caused by consumption of contaminated food or coming in contact with contaminated feces from animals, especially poultry, or people.

Many factors such as temperature, concentration of dissolved organic matters and dissolved minerals can affect the survival of Campylobacter in water.Therefore the survival of the bacteria depends on the conditions of the body of water with studies showing some strains surviving 80 day in artificial water (6).

References
  1. Hardy Diagnostics, Campylobacter, found at https://catalog.hardydiagnostics.com/cp_prod/Content/hugo/Campylobacter.htm
  2. Campylobacter, G. H. Fischer, E. Paterek, In: StatPearls. Treasure Island (FL): StatPearls Publishing, 2020 Jan, found at: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK53
  3. Campylobacter and Helicobacter. G. I. Perez-Perez, M. J. Blaser, S. Baron, editor. Medical Microbiology. 4th edition. Galveston (TX): University of Texas Medical Branch at Galveston, 1996, Chapter 23. Found at https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK8417/
  4. Center for Disease Control and Prevention, Travelers’ health, found at https://wwwnc.cdc.gov/travel/yellowbook/2020/travel-related-infectious-diseases/campylobacteriosis
  5. Campylobacteriosis: A global threat, M. H. Mughal, Biomed J. Sci and Tech Res, 11 (5), 2018, found at https://biomedres.us/pdfs/BJSTR.MS.ID.002165.pdf
  6. Survival in water of Campylobacter jejuni strains isolated from the slaughterhouse, H. Trigui, A. Thibodeau, P. Fravalo, A. Letellier and S. P. Faucher, SpringerPlus 4 (799), 2015, found at https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4688295/#!po=43.1818

Salmonella Bacteria in Water

source (public domain) found at https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Salmonella#/media/File:SalmonellaNIAID.jpg

 

Salmonella are rod shaped, Gram negative, non spore forming, fermenting genera of bacteria from the family Enterobacteriaceae and are facultative anaerobes, which means they can grow in the presence of absence of oxygen. Salmonella bacterial cells are usually 0.7-1.5 micrometers in diameter and 2-5 micrometers long1. Species of Salmonella like S. enterica (with almost all pathogenic Salmonella belonging to the subspecies enterica) are responsible for Gastroenteritis, Salmonellosis, Typhoid and even reactive arthritis after the infection has ended.

Salmonella is one of the most common causes of food-borne illness mainly in developed countries; it is also a major cause of diarrheal diseases in developing countries (1). In fact, Salmonella is 1 of the 4 key global causes of diarrhoeal diseases (2). Sewage overflow, improperly working sewage system, agricultural runoff, storm water runoff and flooding can be the cause of Salmonella presence in water.

Some serotypes (type based on microbial surface) are only found in specific animals or in a single place. Others are found in a variety of animals and all over the world (4).

Transmission of disease can be through contaminated food and water or coming in oral contact with contaminated feces from humans or animals. Salmonella can survive for months in water depending on environmental conditions (2).

  1. Salmonella enterica Serovar Typhimurium Skills To Succeed in the Host: Virulence and Regulation, A. Fàbrega, J. Vila, Clinical Microbiology Reviews, 26 (2), 2013, found at https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3623383/pdf/zcm308.pdf
  2. World Health Organization, Salmonella (non-typhoidal), found at https://www.who.int/news-room/fact-sheets/detail/salmonella-(non-typhoidal)
  3. Our world in data, found at https://ourworldindata.org/childhood-diarrheal-diseases
  4. Center for Disease Control and Prevention, Salmonella, found at https://www.cdc.gov/salmonella/reportspubs/salmonella-atlas/serotyping-importance.html

Water Management Solutions to Solve Poor Drinking Water Problems

Now that we know the dangers of pathogens in water, we should discuss water management and measures to ensure the safety of water.

Water management, part of the broader concept of water cycle management, is planning and managing water resources for optimal use. It’s goal is to protect the lives of humans, animals and the environment. One of the aspects of water management is water quality management. It includes planning, developing and managing:

  • water resources
  • water treatment systems
  • water distribution systems
  • water quality monitoring

to minimize harm to humans, animals and the environment. These steps will ensure that water is safe for use and the quality of the wastewater that is distributed back into the water source like rivers and lakes has an acceptable level of pollutants.

Water Treatment

 

From Visually.

Next we focus on the topics of water treatment and water quality monitoring.

Water Treatment

Water treatment is the process of improving the quality of water for its intended use. It includes completely removing or reducing the concentration of various pollutants. The two main types of water treatment are drinking water treatment and wastewater treatment.

Drinking water treatment prepares safe drinking water for human consumption.

Wastewater treatment prepares water so that it is safe to be released into the environment and in more advanced treatment processes recycled for other purposes.

Drinking Water Treatment Process

Public drinking water systems use different steps to remove the various bacterial contaminants (mentioned above) and provide safe drinking water to consumers. These steps commonly include:

  • coagulation and flocculation
  • sedimentation
  • filtration
  • disinfection

Coagulation and Flocculation

In the coagulation and flocculation step, chemicals with positive electrical charge are added to water. Dirt and dissolved particles are negatively charged and repel each other. The added chemicals will help to overcome those repelling charges and neutralize the negative charge. This way the dirt and dissolved particles bind to the chemicals and form bigger particles called floc. Before the coagulation step, aeration is often used to remove dissolved gases and some metals through oxidation. In the aeration process air is introduced to thin layers of water or bubbles are introduced into the water.

Sedimentation

Sedimentation involves the settlement of floc at the bottom of the water in the sedimentation tank because they are heavy. 27 to 84 percent of viruses and 32 to 87 percent of bacteria can be removed through coagulation, flocculation and consequent sedimentation because they are attached to the dissolved particles.

Filtration

During the filtration process, the top water in the sedimentation tank that has become more clear will move through a series of filters made from sand, gravel and charcoal with different pore sizes. These filters will remove smaller particles like dust, some microorganisms and chemicals.

Disinfection

The previous steps in drinking water treatment cannot completely rid water of any remaining biological contaminants like bacteria, viruses and protozoa. That is why the last step in the drinking water treatment process is disinfection using disinfectants such as chlorine or chloramine; this disinfection is often called chlorination. The disinfectants are added to filtered water and the disinfected water leaves the treatment plant for distribution (1,2).

More recently, Ultra Violet (UV)-based treatment units have replaced the chlorination process as a disinfection step. This is mostly done due to the potential concerns over the formation of disinfection by-products during the chlorination of water that can potentially have adverse health effects like causing cancer and negative environmental impact (3). However, installation of UV treatment units increases both the capital expenditure and operational expenditure of a water treatment plant. This is why chlorination is still the disinfection method of choice for many water treatment plants.

In general, the quality of the water that enters the treatment plant determines the extent of water treatment. Surface water needs more treatment and filtration than groundwater since surface water in lakes, rivers, and streams contains more sediment and pollutants than groundwater. Surface water is also more likely to contain contaminants than groundwater (1,2).

 

Wastewater Treatment Process

The environment has an incredible ability to deal with small amounts of pollution and waste in water, but it cannot cope when dealing with an overwhelming amount of waste (4). 80% of the world’s wastewater, mostly untreated, is released into the environment (5). Moreover, 159 million people drink water directly from untreated surface water sources like streams or lakes (6). In addition, humans use surface water for recreational use. Animals use water to survive. Rivers, oceans and lakes are filled with aquatic species that rely on clean water. That is why treatment of wastewater is crucial for humans and the environment. Since the source of wastewater (e.g. sewage), its pollutants and its purpose differ from drinking water, the process of wastewater treatment is also different.

The type of wastewater treatment process depends on the volume of the wastewater. In general wastewater treatment may consist of primary, secondary and tertiary treatments. Bear in mind that some of these processes are essential regardless of the treatment plant size. Most municipal wastewater treatment facilities implement primary and secondary levels of treatment. Many treat wastewater further via tertiary treatments. The type and the order in which wastewater is treated varies in different treatment plants (7,8).

Primary Treatment

The primary treatment step consists of physical or mechanical processes for wastewater treatment such as sedimentation, screens, sieves or thermal methods.

Solids are firstly removed from wastewater. These solids contain up to 35% of the pollutants that need to be removed. Large solids like garbage, sticks, leaves or paper are omitted using screens that have openings of about 1cm.

After larger items are removed, wastewater is kept in settling tanks, often called clarifiers, for several hours. This way scum will float at the top of the tank and sludge will settle at the bottom of the water. Sludge is eliminated from the bottom and scum is skimmed from the top. The sludge and scum that is removed can also be treated separately to make biofuels. Approximately half of fecal coliforms are removed in this step. The organisms that use the oxygen in the water are also removed therefore bringing the biological oxygen demand (BOD) down to 50 percent (8). The efficiency of a treatment plant is determined based on the extent to which it removes suspended solids, as well as BOD (9).

Secondary Treatment

Secondary treatment involves the use of bacteria with the help of oxygen to consume, break down and digest contaminants. Methods include aeration, anaerobic wastewater treatment, biochemical oxidation, sewage ponds (lagoons) or sludge digestion. The biological process is also referred to as the activated sludge process. This sludge refers to smaller sludge bits that weren’t scraped in primary treatment. Secondary treatment is able to eliminate 85 to 90 percent of BOD and suspended solids. Most of the coliform bacteria, 90 to 95 percent, are removed as well. In some wastewater treatment facilities a sand filter is used to remove additional pollutants. Then the water goes through disinfection with chlorine, ozone, or UV before discharge.

Tertiary Treatment

Tertiary treatment is often referred to as advanced wastewater treatment since

not all treatment plants have the capability of using them. In tertiary treatment, physical, chemical and biological processes are utilized to remove additional pollutants like organic matter, metals, dyes and nutrients, namely phosphorus and nitrogen. Some tertiary treatment processes include biological nutrient removal (BNR), nitrification-denitrification, advanced filtration methods ranging from ultrafiltration, micro-filtration, nano-filtration and reverse osmosis. Secondary clarifiers can also be used as tertiary treatment.

The BNR process uses bacteria to digest pollutants in different tanks with different oxygen levels. Phosphorus is removed in this manner and ammonia breaks down to nitrate and nitrogen gas.

Smaller communities sometimes use lagoons or even septic tanks for primary treatment before they release wastewater into the environment. The water is given time to settle. Where land is available and water cannot flow to nearby bodies of water, biological agents in the soil can help to break down the contaminants in the wastewater. At times these methods may be inadequate for wastewater treatment. Shallow lagoons in particular do not allow enough space for settlement of all pollutants and are not suitable for long term storage of wastewater (8).

 

  1. Center for Disease Control and Prevention, Community water treatment, found at https://www.cdc.gov/healthywater/drinking/public/water_treatment.html
  2. Safe Drinking Water Foundation, Conventional water treatment: coagulation and filtration fact sheet, found at https://www.safewater.org/fact-sheets-1/2017/1/23/conventional-water-treatment
  3. Center for Disease Control and Prevention, Safe water system, Disinfection by-products, found at https://www.cdc.gov/safewater/chlorination-byproducts.html
  4. United States Geological Survey, Wastewater treatment water use, found at https://www.usgs.gov/special-topic/water-science-school/science/wastewater-treatment-water-use?qt-science_center_objects=0#qt-science_center_objects
  5. National Resources Defense Council Water Pollution: Everything You Need to Know, found at https://www.nrdc.org/stories/water-pollution-everything-you-need-know
  6. World Health Organization, public health, environmental and social determinants of health, found at https://www.who.int/mediacentre/infographic/environment/en/
  7. Aerzen, The basic processes of waste water treatment, found at https://www.aerzen.com/applications/water-and-waste-water-treatment/adviser/processes-of-waste-water-treatment.html
  8. Safe Water Drinking Foundation, Wastewater treatment, found at https://www.safewater.org/fact-sheets-1/2017/1/23/wastewater-treatment
  9. Britannica encyclopedia, Wastewater treatment, found at https://www.britannica.com/technology/wastewater-treatment/Sources-of-water-pollution

Water Quality Monitoring

According to the United States Environmental Protection Agency (US EPA), water quality monitoring can be defined broadly as the sampling and analysis of water for its various constituents and conditions (1). These constituents may include:

  • Pollutants entered into the water due to human activities such as oil, pesticides, metals, etc.
  • Natural constituents in water such as dissolved oxygen, nutrients, microorganisms, etc.

As mentioned previously, water quality monitoring is one of the main elements of a successful water management strategy. The concept of water quality monitoring can be used in different applications and for different purposes including:

  • To assure the quality of water satisfies its designated application. Perhaps, the most important designated application of water is for drinking purposes where quality monitoring becomes crucial to ensure water is safe to drink.
  • To detect any potential issue. The sudden increase in the concentration of a chemical compound or bacterial microorganism can be an early warning for a potential problem. For example, sudden increase in the concentration of E.coli in a surface water source downstream of a wastewater treatment plant can indicate potential problems in the wastewater treatment process in the plant.
  • To determine specific pollutants and their potential sources. For example the detection of pesticides in a water stream can point towards a nearby farming operation where the runoff was not managed well.
  • To determine trends. This is especially useful when specific water constituents can be monitored routinely over a specific period of time using a standard method to establish trends.

 

There are a battery of tests to determine the quality of water. That is why “Standard Methods For Examination of Water and Wastewater” has been developed. This collection of more than 400 standard methods has been continuously used and updated since 1905 and is the fruit of the joint collaboration between three well-known technical societies:

 

The following table summarizes various parts of this collection and briefly describes the methods involved in each chapter.

Part No.Part NameDescriptionParameters tested
1000IntroductionThis chapter is intended to provide overall information regarding the methods described in the rest of the collection. General guideline about quality assurance strategies, data quality, collection and preservation of samples, laboratory occupational health and safety as well as waste minimization and waste disposal strategies have been provided in this chapter. However, in each of the following parts, the second chapter always describes the specific quality assurance/quality control measures.Not Applicable
2000Physical and Aggregate PropertiesMethods described in this chapter are used to determine overall physical properties of water samples, regardless of what specific constituents are present in water. Physical properties are used in this chapter in contrast to chemical composition, radioactivity or microbiological properties. However, it is mentioned that in some cases, it is difficult to distinguish between physical properties and chemical properties as both are intertwined. For example, tests for determination of the taste of water samples are included in this chapter although taste is heaviliy dependent on the chemical composition of water.Appearance
Color
Turbidity
Odor
Taste
Flavor profile analysis
Acidity
Alkalinity
Calcium carbonate saturation
Hardness
Oxidant demand/requirement
Conductivity
Salinity
Floatables
Solids
Temperature
Particle counting and size distribution
Asbestos
Oxidation-reduction potential
Tests on sludges
Abaerobic sludge digester gas analysis
Dissolved gas supersaturation
3000MetalsThe effects of the presence of metals in water and wastewater covers the whole range from being essential to the growth of plants and animals, to damaging the treatment processes and finally, imposing toxicity to the users. Moreover, for some metals, the shift in the type of the effects can depend on the concentration. As a result, this part describes a variety of methods that can be used for detection and quantification of metals in water samples depending on the complexity of the water matrix as well as required level of sensitivity and precision. Methods described in this part can be divided into two general categories of colorimetric methods and instrumental methods. As the name suggests, colorimetric methods quantify the metals in a water sample by measuring the degree of color formation in the sample when one specific metal reacts with a specially designed reactant used in the testing process. For example, in colorimetric determination of aluminum in water, Eriochrome cyanine R is used as the reactant. Colorimetric methods are usually simpler and more cost effective compared to instrumental methods; however, they are prone to interferances of other water constituents with the reactant. For instance, phosphate is a known interfering agent in colorimetric detection of aluminum mentioned above. Instrumental methods include tests such as atomic absorption spectrometry, flame photometry, nductively coupled plasma emission spectrometry, anodic stripping voltammetry. The choice of method is heaviliy dependent on the specific metal being detected, complexity of the water matrix, as well as desired detection range. For example, flame atomic absorption methods are normally suited for detection range of 0.1-10 mg/l while more complicated methods such as inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry can offer detection as low as 0.01 µg/l.Aluminum
Arsenic
Calcium
Chromium
Copper
Iron
Lead
Lithium
Magnesium
Manganese
Potassium
Selenium
Sodium
Strontium
Vanadium
Zinc
Other metals (Only contain background information for other matals not included here and refer the reader to the appropriate methods)
4000Inorganic Nonmetalic ConstituentsAs opposed to the previous part, this part of the standard methods deals with the detection and quantification of non-metalic inorganics. In general, this part describes classical wet chemical techniques and their more modern automated variants in quantification of nonmetalic inorganics (e.g. ion chromatography, continuous flow analysis, flow injection analysis, capillary ion electrophoresis) . Of particular importance are methods in quantifcation of constituents such as chlorine, nitrogen and phosphorusSince chlorination is one of the most used disinfection methods in treatment of drinking water, detection of chlorine and its residuals in the treated drinking water and the receiving distribution system is of utmost importance. The presence of residual chlorine (in pre-determined concentration range) in the distribution system can be used as a proxy for assuring the sanitary condition of the water. However, it does not and should not replace the use of microbiological tests described in part 9 (especially Total Coliform and E.coli).

Boron
Bromide
Carbon dioxide
Cyanide
Chlorine (residual)
Chloride
Chlorine dioxide
Fluoride
pH value
Iodine
Iodide
Iodate
Nitrogen
Nitrogen (ammonia)
Nitrogen (nitrite)
Nitrogen (nitrate)
Nitrogen (organic)
Oxygen (dissolved)
Ozone (residual)
Phosphorus
Potassium Permanganate
Silica
Sulfide
Sulfite
Sulfate
Peracetic acid (residual)
Hydrogen peroxide

5000Aggregate Organic ConstituentsIn general, determination methods of organic matters in water and wastewater can be categorized in two groups. This part of standard methods deals with methods that analyze samples for aggregate organics properties. This means that methods presented in this part are concerned with quantification of overall concentration of organic compounds that have common chemical characteristics, regardless of their individual composition. These methods have many applications in analysis of raw & treated wastewater samples since they can assess the efficiency of the treatment process. Methods for quantification of individual organic compounds are presented in the next part.
Some of the most important methods described in this part are:
-Total organic carbon and chemical oxygen demand for analyzing the total amount of organic compounds present.
-Biochemical oxygen demand for assessing the fraction of organic matters that are biodegradable.
-Oil & grease which are defined as all organic compounds that can be extracted from the sample by non polar solvents.
Biochemical Oxygen Demand (BOD)
Chemical Oxygen Demand (COD)
Total Organic Carbon (TOC)
Dissolved organic halogen
Auatic humic substances
Oil & grease
Phenols
Surfactants
Tannin and lignin
Organic and volatile acids
Trihalomethanes and other disinfection byproducts
UV-absorbing organic constituents
6000Individual Organic CompoundsMethods presented in this part are complicated methods for detection and quantification of individual organic compounds at very low concentrations. As a results, for each method, stringent QA/QC protocols have been prescribed. Pre-concentration methods have been instrumental in achieving low levels of detection of organic compounds in water samples. In general, before using methods described here, a pre-concentration step is required to extract organic molecules from a large volume of water sample. Then analysis is done on a much smaller volume of extracted sample. Close-loop Stripping Analysis (CLSA), purge and trap technique and Solid-Phase Micro Extraction (SPME) are the most well-know pre-concentration methods used for preparation of the extracts for analysis. The extracts can be analysed using Gas Chromatography (GC) or Liquid Chromatography (LC) connected to one of several Mass Spectroscopic (MS) detectors.Volatile organic compounds including:
-Methane
-1,2-dibromoethane (EDB) and 1,2-dibromo-3-chloropropame (DBCP)
-Trihalomethanes and chlorinated organic solvents
-Disinfection byproducts: haloacetic acids and trichlorphenol
-Disinfection byproducts: aldehydes
Extractable base/neutrals and acids including:
-Phenols
-Polychlorinated biphenyls
-Polynuclear aromatic hydrocarbons
-Nitrosamines
Carbamate pesticides
Organochlorine pesticides
Acidic herbicide coumpounds
Glyphosphate herbicide
Tributyl tin
Pharmaceuticals and personal care products
7000RadioactivityRadioactivity in water and wastewater samples can stem from natural occurrence as well as human activities. Human activities that can cause the contamination of water and wastewater with radioactive compounds can range from medical and industrial use of radioisotopes to mining and processing of nuclear fuel-related material and atmospheric testing of the nuclear devices.
Testing protocols of water and wastewater samples for radionuclides can range from simple gross alpha and gross beta sreening to more sophistacted methods such as gamma spectroscopy. Gross screening measurements can be inexpensive, simple and quick. This is why these screening methods are normally used to obtain initial assessment and to determine whether further testing of the samples is required. However, these screening methods are subject to bias especially if a high concentration of dissolved solids is present in the sample. Moreover, they do not provide the isotopic composition of the sample and cannot be used to estimate radiation does. To determine the isotpoic composition and radiation dose, more complicated procedures such as gamma spectroscopy is required after the initial screening assessment.
Radioactive cesuim
Radioactive Iodine
Radium
Radon
Total radioactive strontium and strontium-90
Tritium
Uranium
8000ToxicityToxicity tests are important parts of water and wastewater monitoring programs since chemical and physical tests described in previous parts alone do not provide information on the potential effects of contaminations on aquatic biota. Moreover,when exposed to the same level of toxic compounds, the level of susceptibility vary between various aquatic species. Toxicity tests may be used to determine:
– Suitability of environmental conditions for aquatic life
– Effect of environmental parameters on the level of toxicity of compounds
– Toxicity of specific wastes to specific test species
– Relative susceptibility of aquatic species receiving a potentially toxic effluent
– The effluent discharge rate allowed to be received by an aquatic environment
Mutagenesis
Bacterial bioluminescence
P450 reporter gene response to dioxin like organic compounds
Comet/single-cell gel electrophoresis assay for detection of DNA damage
Sediment porewater testing
Algae
Biostimulation (algal productivity)
Phytoplankton
Marine macroalgae
Aquatic flowering plants
Duckweed
Aquatic emergent plants
Ciliated protozoa
Rotifers
Annelids
Mollusks
Arthropods
Daphnia
Ceriodaphnia
Mysids
Decapods
Aquatic insects
Echinoderm fertilization and development
Fish
Fathead minnow
Amphibians
9000Microbiological ExaminationThe methods described in this part of the Standard Methods provide information about the microbiological content of water samples. Since microbiological content of samples are sensitive to the sampling procedures and the sample transportation conditions, the first five chapters of this section are devoted to precise QA/QC procedures, exact laboratory equipment needed for the test methods, how to prepare the equipment through adequate washing and sterilization, preparation of the culture media for methods using such media and, proper sampling and handling. Of particular importance are methods for testing water samples for Total Coliform and E. coli. This is due to the fact that both Total Coliform and E.coli are principal indicators of the suitability of water for domestic, industrial or other uses. Test methods (SM 9221, SM 9222 and SM 9223) for detection and quantification of these indicators in water and wastewater samples have become routine methods in any environmental laboratories that test water and wastewater samples, especially drinking water samples. These methods will be explored in more details in the next section of this article.
This part of the Standard Methods also includes test procedures for differentiating various species in the Total Coliform group. However, for drinking water applications, the differentiation of coliforms is of a very limited use since the presence of the Total Coliform in a drinking water sample renders that water source unsuitable for use, regardless of the exact species present. Although it has to be mentioned that differentiation methods for drinking water can yield valuable information about the source of the pollution or how the distribution system is colonized.
Heterotrophic Plate Count (HPC) methods are also included in this part. These methods provide an approximation of viable bacteria concentration in a water sample without identifying the types. These methods can be used in water treatment plants as in-house testing of the efficiency for various treatment processes or in standard laboratories for testing the quality of the reagent-grade water system.
Test methods for isolating certain pathogenic bacteria or protozoa are also described in this part. These methods are normally very complicated and only used when detailed investigation of waterborne diseases or study of watershed are required.
Rapid detection methods
Stressed microorganisms
Recreational waters
Heterotrophic plate count
Direct total microbial count
Assimilable organic carbon
Aerobic endospores
Multiple-tube fermentation technique for Members of the coliform group
Membrane filter technique for members of the coliform group
Enzyme substrate coliform test
Detection of coliphages
Differentiation of coliform bacteria
Fecal enterococcus/streptococcus groups
Iron and sulfur bacteria
Nitrifying bacteria
Detection of actinomycetes
Detection of pathogenic bacteria
Detection of enteric viruses
Detection of fungi
Pathogenic protozoa
10000Biological ExaminationThe primary goal of this part of the standard methods is to describe protocols for field sample collection and laboratory analysis of water samples to establish the status of the aquatic species present and interpret the effect of current and past contaminations on these species. In other words, while previous parts of the Standard Methods deal with detection and quantification of various pollutants in the water, this part describes how those contaminants (such as turbidity or a chemical substance) can affect these aquatic communities. The aquatic species investigated here are extra to the ones mentioned in the previous section (see the parameter tested for this part). Some of the uses of the information produced by the test protocols in this part are:
– To help interpret chemical analysis, for example, the presence or absence of certain biological species can point toward oxygent deficiency or supersaturation in water samples
– To explain the source of taste, odor, color or visible particulates in the water
– To help in design and operation of water and wastewater treatment plant by investigating the source of the clogging in pipes and filters
– To evaluate the nature and extent of pollutions
– To evaluate the status of self-putification in waterbodies
Plankton
Periphyton
Macrophytes
Benthic macroinvertebrates
Fishes
Benthic meiofauna
Nematological examination
Identification of aquatic organisms

Microbiological Water Testing - What do you Test for?

As described in the previous sections, Standard Methods (SM) for Examination of Water and Wastewater provides a detailed explanation of various testing methods for determining the quality of water and wastewater by analyzing a variety of parameters, from metals to organic compounds and microorganisms.

Part 9 (SM 9xxx) is dedicated to all the methods for microbiological examination of water and wastewater samples. The table in the previous section lists all the microorganisms or parameters that can be tested with SM 9xxx. From all the methods in part 9, methods for detection and quantification of Total Coliform and E.coli are of the utmost importance. As mentioned, this is due to the fact that Total Coliform and E.coli are used as the microbial indicators in water quality management and represent the effectiveness of the utilized water or wastewater treatment systems in removing microorganisms.

As a result, millions of water (from both drinking water treatment units and the receiving distribution systems) and wastewater samples (usually treated effluents) are tested every year as parts of regular checks to make sure drinking water is safe for consumption and treated wastewater is suited for discharge into the environment.

In part 9 of the Standard Methods, three methods are dedicated to detection and quantification of Total Coliform and E.coli. These are:

  • SM 9221: Multiple-tube fermentation technique for members of the coliform group
  • SM 9222: Membrane filter technique for members of the coliform group
  • SM 9223: Enzyme substrate coliform test

The following sections are only intended to provide a general overview of each standard method. More detailed information on specific protocols and procedures can be found in the Standard Methods reference document.

SM 9221: Multiple-Tube Fermentation (MTF)

MTF is perhaps the oldest method of testing samples for Total Coliform and E.coli. Fundamentally, the method works based on the fact that members of the Coliform group metabolize lactose. As a result, MTF utilizes lactose broth in combination with other compounds and detects the metabolism based on the formation of gas and acids in the test tubes. Gas formation can be observed by formation of visible gas bubbles in the tubes while the acid production changes the color of the medium.

MTF tests are done in three stages of presumptive tests, confirmatory tests and completed tests. It has to be mentioned that if in the presumptive stage, no gas formation or color change (due to acid production) is observed in any of the tubes, the sample is rendered safe, meaning confirmatory and completed stages are no longer required. If however, gas formation and color change are observed in the test tubes, water is unsafe and positive test tubes enter the confirmatory stage.

The following describes the procedure used in the presumptive stage.

  1. The lactose broth (the medium) is made by mixing the required ingredients (refer to the SM 9221 section of the Standard Method) in laboratory grade reagent water. The media is prepared in both single and double strength concentrations.
  2. Dispense enough media into predetermined number of test tubes depending on the nature of the sample:
    1. For treated samples (such as drinking water), put 10 ml of the double strength medium in each of 5 tubes while dispensing 50 ml of the single strength medium in only 1 tube.
    2. For untreated samples (polluted such as surface water or sewage effluent), put 10 ml of the double strength medium in each of 5 tubes while dispensing 10 ml of the single strength medium in 10 tubes.
    3. Remember to put the inverted Durham tubes inside each test tube for observing the gas bubble formation.
  1. Add the sample to the tubes depending on on the nature of the sample:
    1. For treated samples, add 10 ml of the sample to each of the 5 tubes containing 10 ml of the double strength medium. Add 50 ml of the sample to the 1 tube that contains 50 ml of the single strength medium.
    2. For untreated samples, there are three aliquots as shown in the schematic below:
      1. For each of the 5 tubes containing 10 ml of the double strength medium, add 10 ml of the sample.
      2. For 5 of the 10 tubes containing 10 ml of the single strength medium, add 1 ml of the sample to each.
      3. For the rest of the 5 tubes with 10 ml of the single strength medium, add 0.1 ml of the sample to each.
source microbeonline.com/probable-number-mpn-test-principle-procedure-results

Schematic showing the presumptive stage of MTF for untreated (polluted) samples

  1. Incubate all the tubes in the oven at 35 oC. After 24 hours of incubation, observe the tubes for any evidence of gas formation (gas bubbles) or acid formation (shade of yellow color). If no gas or acid formation is evident in any of the tubes, reincubate at the same temperature for another 24 hours. Observe the samples again. No gas or acid formation means the sample does not contain Total Coliform. However, if any sign of gas or acid formation is observed, refer to the appropriate table for estimating the Total Coliform concentration based on Most Probable Number Method (MPN). Make sure to use the correct table based on the sample type.

For treated samples:

MPN values per 100-ml of sample and 95% confidence limits for various combinations of positive and negative results (when one 50-ml and five 10-ml test portions are used) source microbeonline.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/06/Multiple-Tube-Method-for-Thermotolerant-Faecal-Coliform.pdf

For untreated samples:



MPN values per 100-ml of sample and 95% confidence limits for various combinations of positive and negative results (when five 10-ml, five 1-ml and five 0.1-ml test portions are used) source microbeonline.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/06/Multiple-Tube-Method-for-Thermotolerant-Faecal-Coliform.pdf

As can be seen from this description, the MFT is a very complicated test method, bare in mind that the above-mentioned protocol is only for the presumptive stage. If the presumptive stage shows any positive test tubes, those tubes should enter the confirmatory and completed test stages which are even more complicated and out of the scope of the article. Suffice to say that during the completed test stage, a loopful of the samples in the positive tubes during the confirmatory stage are streaked onto plates containing highly selective medium such as Eosin Methylene Blue. A set of plates is incubated at 35 oC for Total Coliform completed test results (formation of colonies with green sheen) while another set is incubated at 44.5 oC for thermotolerant E.coli completed results.

Beside being complicated, MFT method is a lengthy test method that requires many glassware and media and can take up to 4-5 days to yield results.

SM 9222: Membrane filter (MF)

Membrane filter technique was developed in the early 1950s in response to the fact that the MFT method described in the previous section is very labor intensive and time consuming. More importantly, as opposed to the MFT method that provides an estimation of the bacteria concentration using MPN tables, MF method gives the direct count of the bacterial colonies in the sample. This is simply why the MF method is one of the most used methods in the environmental laboratories for routine microbiological examination of water and wastewater samples.

A simple schematic of the MF method for testing water samples to source microdok.com/membrane-filtration-technique/

Detection and quantification of Total Coliform and E.coli by MF is done simply by the following steps.

  1. Vacuum filtration or suction flask apparatus is assembled. This assembly includes a water reservoir that holds the water sample (1), a filter paper (most often with the pore size of 0.45 µm) and a receiving tank that is connected to a vacuum pump. For testing drinking water, at least 100 ml is used. The filter is a thin porous sheet made of polymers such as cellulose esters and is designed to trap and capture bacteria. The vacuum pump is used to push the water through the membrane.
  2. After filtration is done, the filtration setup is disassembled and the membrane is removed.
  3. Membrane is placed in a sterile petri dish containing a pad saturated with the required medium.
  4. Upon incubation of the petri dish in the oven at 35 oC, colonies with different colors are formed. Depending on the type of the procedure used, the colors indicate what type of bacteria is in the sample (Total Coliform, E.coli, or non-coliform). The count of each colony type is represented as Colony Forming Unit (CFU) that shows the concentration of that type in the sample.

There are multiple procedures described in SM 9222 for detection of Total Coliform and E.coli. These procedures are more or less the same in the steps, with the main difference of compounds used in preparation of the selective medium are different. This change in the compounds dictates how the target bacteria is detected in the process. These procedures are:

  • Endo-type agar medium containing lactose which is designed for detection and quantification of Total Coliform only. In the procedure, coliform bacteria are defined as colonies that show golden-green metallic sheen upon incubation at 35 oC for 24 hours. Generally, colonies with any other color (pink, blue, colorless) are categorized as non-coliforms in this technique.
  • Dual-chromogen m-ColiBlue24 medium that is designed for simultaneous detection and quantification of Total Coliform and E.coli in a sample. In this procedure, the medium contains lactose and a non-selective dye called TTC that produce Total Coliform colonies with a red color upon incubation at 35 oC for 24 h. Since E.coli is part of the Total Coliform family, to differentiate E.coli colonies, the medium in this method also contains a selective compound known as BCIG that reacts specifically with the enzyme (ß-glucuronidase) produced only by E.coli cells. This reaction creates E.coli colonies that are blue to purple.
  • Fluorogen/chromogen MI medium that is also designed to simultaneously detect and quantify Total Coliform and E.coli. This procedure is very similar to the previous method with the main difference being that both Total Coliform and E.coli are detected by their enzymatic activity in this method. The medium in this test method includes a fluorogen known as MUGal and reacts with ß-galactosidase enzyme produced by Total Coliform. As a result, Total Coliform colonies will be fluorescent under UV light in this method. On the other hand, to differentiate E.coli, the medium includes a chromogen known IBDG that detects ß-glucuronidase enzyme produced by E.coli and creates blue colonies on the plate upon incubation at 35 oC for 24 hors.

Overall, the MF method is more versatile and simple compared to the MTF method and yields results that are more accurate. However, it cannot be used for samples with high turbidity.

SM 9223: Enzyme substrate

Enzyme substrate methods for detection and quantification of Total Coliform and E.coli in water and wastewater samples are the most recent addition to the Standard Methods.

The working principle of these methods is very similar to the Fluorogen/chromogen MI procedure used in the membrane filter method explained above where detection is done by the enzymatic action of bacteria on specific substrates in the medium. That action either produces color ro fluorescent signature. However, instead of counting colonies, the quantification principle is very similar to the MTF method where tests are done in a series of tubes or wells and statistical means are used to quantify the concentration of the target bacteria. As a result, similar to MTF methods, enzyme substrate methods provide the bacteria concentration with the Most Probable Number (MPN) unit.

In quantification of Total Coliforms, enzyme substrate methods use the chromogenic substrates known as ONPG and CPRG. In the test process, Total Coliforms produce the ß-galactosidase enzyme which hydrolyzes the substrates and produces a yellowish color. It is known that some other non-coliforms such as Pseudomonas can produce small amounts of the ß-galactosidase enzyme that can create false positives in the test. However, the medium includes compounds that suppress the activity of non-coliforms. As a result, false positives from these non-coliforms are generally avoided, unless they are present at very high concentrations (>106CFU/100 ml).

Quantitative analysis of E.coli is achieved by the fluorogenic substrates known as MUG. The ß-glucuronidase enzyme produced by E.colicells reacts with this substrate and creates a bluish fluorescence under the UV irradiation. It is important to remember that the color change together with the presence of fluorescence in the sample indicates the presence of E.coli. This is because some strains of other species such as Salmonella can also produce fluorescence but since they lack the production of the ß-galactosidase enzyme, they cannot cause the color change.

IDEXX Colilert-18 Quanti-Trays are perhaps one of the most used technologies currently in the environmental laboratories that belong to the enzyme substrate method. In this procedure, 96-well trays are used that are similar to the image below.

Image of a 96-well tray used on the IDEXX Colilert tests source fishersci.co.uk/shop/products/colilert-colilert-18-comparator-2/p-7162351

100 ml of the water sample is added to the dry powder that contains all the necessary compounds for the reaction medium (chromogen, fluoregen, suppressants, etc.). The sample is shaken to dissolve all the chemicals and then is poured over the tray so all the 96 wells (48 large and 48 small wells). The tray is then sealed using a Quanti-Tray system and is kept in the oven at 35 oC for 24 hours. The following image shows the tray after incubation if Total Coliform and E.coli are present.

(A) Wells with the yellow color indicate the presence of Total Coliform (B) Wells that showed the color change and also the blue fluorescence under the UV light indicate the presence of E.coli source sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0167701219300107

The number of positive wells for each type of bacteria is then compared to standard tables and the concentration of Total Coliform and E.coli is presented with the MPN unit.

Enzyme substrate methods are the simplest of the test methods for quantification of Total Coliform and E.coli and they require lower expertise and equipment to be performed. However, they still require laboratory facility and cannot provide results in less than 24 h, similar to the MFT and MF methods discussed in this section.

The next section describes why new methods are still required to enable both onsite and rapid testing of water samples.

A Better Water Testing Process

As described extensively in this article, water quality monitoring via regular testing of water samples is a cornerstone of any water management strategy and it is the first line of defense against any potential problems.

Regular testing of water samples for Total Coliform and E.coli has become increasingly important since they show if water is safe for human consumption and whether the treatment units and the distribution system are functioning properly or not.

Standard tests used for detection and quantification of Total Coliform and E.coli in water and wastewater samples were discussed in the previous section. Regardless of the complexity of each method, all three methods discussed in the previous section have two features in common. These are:

  • All methods require central laboratory facilities to house the procedure;
  • All methods require at least 24 hours to yield results.

The fact that central laboratories are needed to perform the tests simply means that these tests are unavailable in many regions around the world, especially remote and small communities in developing countries. At the beginning of this article, we shared statistics about how these regions suffer from consequences of drinking unsafe water everyday.

The fact that current test methods need at least 24 hours to yield results means that even in regions around the world that have access to laboratory facilities, truly efficient water management strategies cannot be implemented since these strategies need real-time data as the input to enable real-time decision making.

Active boil water advisories in Canada (as of  Feb 2, 2021) (For Current Advisories Visit https://www.watertoday.ca/map-graphic.asp)

Statistically, 25% of these boil water advisories are directly because Total Coliform and E.coli were found in the water. Usually, boil water advisories are lifted after 48 hours on average, many of these boil water advisories can stay in effect for weeks, months and in some rare cases years.

Alongside other deficiencies in the waterworks systems of some of these regions, boil water advisories are stretched because lifting them needs test data to make sure water is safe and tests are only done in central laboratories and require time to provide the much needed data.

This is one of the many examples of why truly efficient water management strategies are in need of technologies that can provide real-time data so decisions can be made in real-time and onsite.

The above-mentioned discussion is precisely why we at Roshan Water™ Solutions have created VeloCens™. Although more information and specifications can be found on the VeloCens™ page, here we explain how our product solves the problems of 24 hour or more turnaround and central lab access requirements.

VeloCens™ is a portable device that quantitatively tests water samples for E.coli and Total Coliform in 1 hour.

The fact that the device is portable means that tests can be done anywhere. Moreover, the test protocol is easy so anyone can do it. This means that the necessary data can be generated onsite and the nanotechnology used in the test cartridges, allows for test results to be ready within 1 hour. The following graph is included to help explain how VeloCens™ can do the tests rapidly and what the role of the nanostructures are in this process.

Bacterial growth curve as a function of incubation time (Source: thoughtco.com/bacterial-growth-curve-phases-4172692)

The bacterial growth curve shown in the above graph is a typical growth curve when bacteria (live) is incubated with enough nutrition to grow. The curve has 4 distinct phases:

  • Lag: This is the initial phase where the original population of the bacteria in the sample use the nutrition and prepare for the cell division. In this phase, cells have metabolic activity, become larger but they are not ready yet to increase in population.
  • Exponential: In this phase, cell population increases significantly through the binary fission process. Metabolic activity is at its highest stage and all sorts of components such as DNA, RNA and cell walls are generated.
  • Stationary: Over time, the increase in the cell population declines as the medium is depleted from available nutrition and accumulation of waste starts. This phase is represented by a plateau since the rates of cell growth and death match each other.
  • Death: This phase is fundamentally the continuation of the previous phase but in this phase the rate of cell death overcomes the growth rate simply because nutrients are almost unavailable and the medium is saturated with waste.

All the current slow and laborious testing methods are heavily dependent on the exponential phase.

In this phase the population of the cells is so high that they form visible countable colonies on the membrane (for the MF method); or the metabolic activity is so significant (visible gas bubble formation in MFT) that it reacts with the substrates and imparts visible changes to the color or fluorescent properties of the solution (in enzyme substrate methods). For Total Coliform and E.coli tests, the time to reach enough growth rate so the changes become visible is 24-48 hours. That is the reason why the current standard tests need this period of time to produce the results.

VeloCens™ also uses the same natural fundamental mechanisms in the cell growth to detect the target bacteria. However, instead of relying on the exponential phase, VeloCensworks in the lag phase.In the lag phase, the cells still have their normal metabolic activity, however they are much smaller compared to the growth phase. The nanostructures used in VeloCenscartridges are designed to be very sensitive to the metabolic activity of the cells.

As a result, even minute metabolism of the cells can be detected in the sample.

Finally, the engineering of these nanostructures, along with the blend of suppressants used in the test reagents impart the selectivity needed to deliver accurate test results in 1 hour.

Water for Life

Access to clean and safe drinking water is a global challenge. As a result it requires global initiatives and partnerships to solve it. The list of innovative companies such as Roshan Water™ who are trying to be part of the solution is endless. There are also massive local and global initiatives that are designed to solve water challenges in locations where clean drinking water is an everyday challenge.

Perhaps one of the most important initiatives in this category is currently being conducted by UNICEF called the Rapid E.coli Detection Project. The main goal of this program is for UNICEF to work with technology providers and “empower communities and government partners with key information on water quality”. This in turn will help these communities to treat unsafe water sources and identify areas where improvements are needed.

In this project,UNICEF is looking for technologies that allow testing water samples for E.coli to happen onsite and rapidly (within a few hours). One of the main applications for such technologies in this UNICEF project is performing household surveys of water quality in countries where UNICEF is providing support. UNICEF supports approximately 100 household surveys per year and on average each survey covers about 50,000 homes. This translates to roughly 1 million water tests per year to make sure the drinking water in these regions is safe for consumption.

There are many non-for profit organizations such as Humanity First and Ryan’s Well Foundation who actively conduct projects in rural areas in Africa, South East Asia, etc. with the goal to build water wells and hand pumps with enough sanitary conditions so the local population can have access to safe drinking water in their own community, without the need to travel for kilometers to reach one.

TLDR; Summary

More than 2 billion people use a drinking water source that is contaminated with feces causing about 829,000 deaths per year due to unsafe drinking water. Diarrheal diseases claim the lives of roughly 5,000 children every day! The staggering approximately 1,200 deaths in children per day is linked to unsafe drinking water.

  • Water may make up 71% of the surface of planet earth, but only 2.5% of this water is considered fresh water.
  • Only 0.5% of the earth’s water is available to use.
  • More than 2 billion people use a drinking water source that is contaminated with feces causing about 829,000 deaths per year due to unsafe drinking water.
  • The leading cause of diarrheal death in children is unsafe drinking water with almost 1,200 deaths per day.
  • 18 million cases of waterborne diseases are reported in North America every year.
  • At any given time, one in five indigenous communities in Canada is under a form of drinking water advisory.
  • Reuse and recycling of wastewater (especially for irrigation), water quality monitoring, reversing climate change and conserving water as a few of the steps we can take to battle water stress in the world.
  • The important role of E. coli and Total Coliforms in water is that they are indicator organisms that can determine the presence of pathogens in water and its safety.
  • Total Coliform and E.coli are used as the microbial indicators in water quality management and represent the effectiveness of the utilized water or wastewater treatment systems in removing microorganisms.
  • The most common ways for bacteria to end up in water are Inadequate water treatment, Sewage overflow, Improperly working sewage system, Agricultural runoff, Storm water runoff and Flooding.
  • Water management, part of the broader concept of water cycle management, is planning and managing water resources for optimal use.
  • Water quality monitoring is one of the main elements of a successful water management strategy
  • There is a wide range of standard test procedures for analyzing the quality of water.
  • Specific to the microbiological examination of water samples, tests are done in central laboratories and yield results at least 24 h later.
  • Real-time decision making based on real-time data has become a cornerstone of modern efficient water management strategies.
  • These strategies are seeking technologies that can test water samples onsite and faster.
  • VeloCens™ is a portable device that quantitatively tests water samples for E.coli and Total Coliform in 1 hour.

 

Overall, access to safe and clean water and assuring its safety is a global challenge. Monitoring the quality of water through testing is the first crucial step in resolving this challenge.Efficient strategies include decentralized, rapid testing for real-time decision making. VeloCens™ is a part of this solution for on-demand, onsite and rapid microbiological testing of water. It is a portable device that has the capability to quantitatively test water samples for E.coli and Total Coliform in 1 hour.

Portable Microbiological Water Testing Lab

Roshan Water™ has a long-term vision to deploy VeloCens™ in rural communities in developing countries to help people who are suffering the most from the consequences of drinking unsafe water.